Socratic Elenchus (logical disputation)

Multivariate Media Complexes:
Parallelism in Verbal and Visible Communication


Click Logo to progress and browser arrow to regress.


Abstract

The increased volume of messages and communication techniques since 1950 requires communicators to become dependent on, and involved with, technology and applications development. Message creation, transmission, and presentation have become major industries supporting large segments of the economy. Words and pictures, and the interpreted ideas and images have a stronger influence on the beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors of more people than ever before. The transmitters and receivers of messages need increasingly versatile and effective media for handling the complex interactions and information on which contemporary society depends. Consequently, technologists have created new communications tools to deliver messages in multiple modes and media. The new media, new message forms, new persuasion techniques, and new strategies for various audience types require a new approach to rhetorical theory (Bitzer 1971).

This dissertation argues that rhetoricians need to expand their theories to encompass the requirements of a modern technological society. It explores how they can widen the scope of rhetorical theory and practice and suggests ways that they can construct visible and kinetographic (verbal/visible) language theories that support communication in new technological environments. The author also explains how rhetoricians (and consequently writers, graphic designers, and computer programmers) can recognize and explore non-traditional communication procedures and practices when dealing with the electronic dissemination of information.

Heretofore, rhetoricians have restricted themselves to forms of classical oral and verbal rhetoric that do not take into consideration visible language. Consequently, kinetography (verbal/visible rhetoric) performs an important role in technological communication because it comprises both verbal and visible elements. Kinetography becomes a means to communicate information that emanates from interdisciplinary activity to a specific audience. This information results from the interaction of two or more disciplines that function as significant units: significant because they evoke an aesthetic response or ethos that precedes the conveyance of meaning (the coordinated function that creates communication). This contrasts with multidisciplinary means of communication that combine many disciplines and methods (a complex organization of the content of communication) without necessarily improving the information transfer.

Kinetography, primarily defined as a dynamic, secondary orality or technological verbal/visible rhetoric, applies to multivariate online, interactive, and broadcast media. As rhetoric, it contrasts with the accepted concept of classical rhetoric: the organization of oral and written discourse. Kinetographic complexities relate in terms of function rather than in terms of organization and have parallel verbal/visible significance.

The practices of the sophists, the writings of Isocrates and Cicero, and the paradigms of many twentieth-century critics relate to one classical method of rhetoric: an oral and written process. This process requires the speaker or writer to achieve an immediate goal and to influence an audience by persuading them to accept a particular point of view. This traditional concept of rhetoric becomes inadequate for application in modern technological environments: it needs study and eventual change. Consequently, if contemporary rhetoric must experience change, then rhetorical paradigms also require change (Brockreide 1971).

Rhetoricians need to explore non-traditional communication processes concurrently with learning the techniques associated with the new computerized tools. They must invent new ways to improve comprehension in complex technological environments, environments that require them to widen the scope of rhetorical theory to accommodate both verbal and visible languages. The study of kinetography proposes the construction of new parallel verbal/visible language theories and uses an historical approach to incorporate existing empirical methods.


Endnotes and citations appear in the PDF and bibliography.


A proposal for a dissertation to be submitted
in partial fulfillment of the
requirements for the degree of
Doctor of Philosophy
Eindhoven University of Technology
(12 July 1993)



Paul Trummel PhD (RPI ABD), PhD (UW ABD), MS (RPI), MSc (UK), BSc (UK)
UK degree equivalencies in graphic communication recognized by
Boston University, Northeastern University, Rochester Institute of Technology,
Fitchburg State College, San Jose State University,
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, and University of Washington
with comparability twice certified by International Education Research Foundation (IERF),
a credential evaluation service accredited by US Department of Education

Associate Professor, Communication and Rhetoric (Retired)
Special Doctor of Philosophy Program (SPhD), University of Washington
Fellow, International Society of Typographic Designers (FISTD)
Fellow, Institute of Paper Printing and Publishing (FIOP)
Member, Society of Authors, London

International Federation of Journalists, Brussels (International Press Card)
National Union of Journalists, London (UK Press Card)

ContraCabal Home Page

CONTENTS

ContraCabal.nets

ContraCabal.orgs

ContraCabal.com

ContraCabal.eus

© Copyright 1992 by Paul Trummel
All Rights Reserved: 29 Sep 92/12:00 GMT
Edition: #202-00-00/07-0926-19:29
Feedback: Webspinner+ContraCabal.org


ContraCabal.org
ContraCabal.net
ContraCabal.com
ContraCabal.us


ContraCabal.org Home Page

Rensselaer and
University of Washington

History of Abuse

The author compiled a body of academic work (now in process of restoration on this web site) during more than a decade of doctoral research.

The data resided on mainframe computers at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (NY) and University of Washington (WA) as text and graphics.

Ronald A. Johnson, Vice President, Computing & Communications, UW and
S. Michael Halloran, formerly Chairperson now Professor, LL&C/H&SS, RPI, arbitrarily closed computer accounts in breach of contract and without due process of law in violation of university regulations.

Johnson and Halloran then maliciously destroyed or otherwise denied access to the content of those databases in attempts to "disappear" the author.

University officials later forged or destroyed official transcripts to support their false and misleading contentions.


Wilfully blind, presidents of two universities continue to do nothing about the abuse.

Shirley Ann Jackson, President, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Mark A. Emmert, President, University of Washington


Shirley Ann Jackson, Rensselaer and
Mark A. Emmert,
University of Washington
hold ultimate responsibility for multiple violation of civil and human rights.

Whoever knows that a subordinate has committed an offense and remains silent to hinder or prevent prosecution or punishment becomes an accessory after the fact.

Reconstructed databases containing all of the required work for two PhD degrees (all of it published and most of it peer-reviewed) will appear in due course.

Due to the small capacity of personal computer hard drives and accessories of a previous era, no independent backup data exists except some incomplete original drafts.

The author will reconstruct graphics as far as possible.

Meanwhile, scanned images occupy some pages pending retyping or reformatting text and redrawing graphics.

Many of the originals reside in special archives in Europe to which the author does not now have access because of removal of his academic status, library privileges, and computer access.

Many illustrations will need replacement which means establishing new sources.

The publications list also contains some interesting documents selected from probably thousands produced using cutting-edge technology in more than sixty years of writing, graphic design, and systems invention.

In some cases, the author developed the technology to meet the need for specialized digital publication.

Several of the document paradigms resulted in typographic encoding which later supported desktop publishing systems.


Letters to the Editor

Letters should not exceed 250 words, with preference given to those letters responding to articles published in Contra Cabal.

Letters must include the author's name, city, and state, email address, and a phone number for contact and verification.

The Editor reserves the right to edit letters for length and clarity and not to publish all letters.

By submission of a letter, the author agrees that Contra Cabal may publish and/or license the publication of letters in print, electronically, and for archival purposes.


About the Author

Paul Trummel (Nmesis)

Paul Trummel, published since 1944, uses the pseudonym Nmesis and openly declares personal or conflicting interests.

These conflicts may relate to topics or to opinion, especially when the content draws upon advocacy, experience, conclusion, or interpretation.

As an accredited journalist, he conforms with the code of conduct and ethics of the journalism profession, tested by courts in both Great Britain and the USA.

Since 1947, he has worked as a journalist, an editor (commercial and academic peer-review), a technical communicator, an associate professor (visual communi-cation and rhetoric), and as an administrator at several leading universities.

He has held international press credentials since 1959 and holds two elected international graphic arts fellowships.

He earned professional letters in the UK that translated into two baccalaureate degrees and a terminal graduate degree in the US.

He has also earned a Rensselaer graduate degree and two US PhD degrees (now ABD).

[Sherking Responsibility]

He taught graduate level students at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Northeastern University, Fitchburg State College,
San Jose State University, Massachusetts Bay Community College, and a private institute of graphic design.

He held an administrative post at University of Massachusetts, Boston, and has lectured at universities in US, Europe, and Japan.

In 1957 (London), he founded and operated the first full-service technical communication organization, a group of publishing and technical/graphic communication companies where he held the position of chief executive officer.

In 1973 (Connecticut), he designed and marketed the first typesetting system driven by a minicomputer, the precursor for today's desktop publishing systems.

He has won an international silver medal for his satire and a US city award for his educational programs for disadvantaged people.

Since 1992, he has investigated and written several hundred articles on bureaucratic and elder abuse.

He founded Contra Cabal, one of the first electronic magazines to appear on the web, for which he develops the site, writes articles, designs pages, and produces graphics.

http://ContraCabal.org

Contra Cabal has now published for almost fifteen years.

Earlier, it published as email for six years. The hits/month now range between 100,000 and 150,000 with more than a million hits during the past twelve months.

Articles cover ongoing criminal activity by bureaucrats and elder abuse.

They describe the actions of corrupt judges and gross misconduct by lawyers who file frivolous law suits against tenants in government financially-assisted housing.

They outline how managers use unlawful retaliatory measures and propaganda to destroy the reputations of people who report illegal activity and racism.

Washington Supreme Court unanimously reversed a lower court decision that effectively allowed prior restraint and defined journalism inquiry as surveillance and harassment.

Repeatedly, lawyers who could find no fault with content instead personally attacked the author or his genre.

A corrupt judge imposed prior restraint and jailed him for contempt when he challenged the court decisions as a basic violation of constitutional and human rights.

To further coerce him, in consort with other jurists, the judge then arbitrarily transferred him to solitary confinement among murderers and rapists.

His published work in the print media for more than sixty years has received no challenge relating to accuracy.

People, among them elected judges and lawyers upon whom the public should be able to rely, have tried to stop him publishing information on politically sensitive issues.

That prior restraint, and restrictions on personal mobility, has now become a matter of international concern.

American Civil Liberties Union
(ACLU - Seattle),
International Federation of Journalists
(IFJ- Brussels),
National Union of Journalists
(NUJ - London),
American Society of Authors and Editors
(ASAE - New York),
and Seattle Weekly
have all filed amicus curiae briefs with Washington Supreme Court in support of his successful First Amendment stance.

Credential validation upon request by journalists and other responsible parties from: